What constitutes a government? Is it the force behind a large nation? Or can a government be found on a small island where one shipwrecked man fights to survive? In reading one of the greatest classics, Robinson Crusoe, I couldn't help but compare the way that he, Robinson Crusoe, governs "his man Friday", to how our government governs us today. Several things in particular that I noted from the way he governs Friday versus how our government works are things like, how they differ in their governing, how they treat those they govern, and what their perception of the governed are. When we look at a story of such significance in actually shaping great governments, we can start to understand and bring out the fundamental flaws that have been hiding in our modern system of government.
How does Washington treat it's citizens? Each day it seems we hear of some new law or act of government welfare. Our government constantly is bailing people out, spending imaginary money on, and "helping" people. In contrast, we see Robinson Crusoe who, though he helps Friday, is going about doing that in a totally different way. He always has Friday's welfare at heart, even if it is only for the purpose of keeping him alive to be his slave. But instead of just pampering him and not allowing him to fail, he is constantly teaching him how to take care of himself. He teaches him how to use tools, how to read, how and what to worship. Once more, we see a point to compare. Our government is constantly promoting education, but not the purpose behind it. Likewise to Crusoe, our government promotes jobs and working under others. As we look at this, we see the sound judgement behind Crusoe, and find some flaws in our government. Flaws like over-excessive debt, promoting idleness through welfare, and not giving people the opportunity to try-with the pretense of not wanting them to fail. But these are only a few of the flaws that we will uncover as we look at it from the perspective of "My Man Friday".
What were some of the tactics that Crusoe used in his governing? This is where we start to see similarities that startlingly similar. We see Crusoe setting himself up as a superior in all ways. He is better than Friday at the language, he is Fridays portal to God. He's the one that Friday needs to survive. By doing that, Crusoe gains all power over Friday. Similarly we see our government setting up a superiority complex over the masses. By using the welfare, complicated wording in legislation, long dry debates, and high standards of living, our government sets themselves above the masses. When they do that, it creates a wide gap between them and the government. We are starting to see the shadows of an aristocracy forming.
We also see the contrasting views of who their governed are. Robinson Crusoe sees Friday as a lesser race, but still as a human. In his work with Friday, we see him taking the responsibility to govern because it is his right. At the same time, he treats him as a fellow human, but one of a lesser class and age. Here we see a very strict caste system. A system that is based on an assumption that one man is inherently better than another. In contrast, the United States is infamous for its over-the-top equality. The government is constantly promoting equal rights, supplying equal things, and, in short, trying to erase all distinction. This is not bad. Equality is good, if you go about it the right way. Which we don't. But even with all those taxpayers dollars being invested into breaking those gaps, we are only forming larger rifts! As we pointed out before, the government is making it so, "in the name of equality" an aristocracy is forming. We see the rich getting richer (and more politically powerful) and the poor getting poorer (and exponentially less powerful in politics). This is a fundamental flaw the plagues our nation today. And the rift is only getting wider.
In looking at a classic of such renown, we have been able to uncover many flaws lurking in the shadows of our government. We have seen things like debt, welfare, government regulation, as well as many others. These and other things are increasing the feeling of aristocracy in America. It's our responsibility to change this. If we sit by and watch as these flaws ferment into something far worse, then we will have that much of a harder time fixing things. We need more people who do not rely on the government for their living. We need to start building small businesses to fight poverty. We need to become more involved in our future, and not give all the power to Washington and let them run wild. Specifically we need to abolish the seventeenth amendment. This will move power back into our states, and help to keep Washington in the peoples hands. If we do this, our government may once more become on "of the people, by the people, and for the people". That's the real kind of government.